# Sympathy

## A 'Melancholy of Suzumiya Haruhi' fanfiction

### Chapter Four -- Millennium

Disclaimer: The novel series of Suzumiya Haruhi that began with 'The
Melancholy of Suzumiya Haruhi' is the creation of Nagaru Tanigawa. No
disrespect is intended by the posting of this fanfiction, as I do not own the
characters or settings involved. I'm merely dabbling with another set of
paints.

* * *

Nothing really exciting happens in club the next few days. That's fine, since
we're gearing up for something this weekend. Koizumi-kun brings in some board
games and card-games-- He tries to bring in some handheld gaming systems too,
but he and Kyon are annoying enough about talking about video games all the
time anyway, so I ban those before it can take off. Neither of them mind too
much about that -- which is how I think it should be.

Anyway, what's the point of a game that only Kyon and Koizumi-kun play? Even
Mikuru-chan and Yuki join in on the board games once in a while. I might join
in once in a while too, if I weren't still annoyed with Yuki.

But she mostly keeps to herself and doesn't try to pull any other pranks.

I practice my sleight of hand with the toothpicks as much as I can, but I
really need other people to try it out _with_, and that's hard to pull off
without giving everything away.... I still think I have it down pretty well,
though.

Better, everyone shows up when I expect them to-- Well, mostly.

Yuki is waiting for _me_ when I show up at the train station -- Mikuru-chan
doesn't take much longer. Kyon manages to show up three minutes late, and I
give him a sharp glare, but it's Koizumi-kun who's the last to arrive.

"Penalty!" I declare, pointing between them. Kyon looks at me, frowning, and I
relent, "Kyon, you can slide just this once." He raises his eyebrows at that,
but he did help me out with my homework. Not that I'm about to say that in
front of the others! Anyway -- this makes us square; I'm forgiving
insubordination, here! "Koizumi-kun, you were even later-- That means you have
to pay for our meals!"

"Okay," he says with an easy grin, shrugging. "I can do that."

Well -- that seems fine to me, then. Kyon gives Koizumi-kun a curious look,
but the boy with the mussed hair just says, "I did sleep in-- Up too late last
night playing 'Devil Survivor.'"

"Oh, which ending are you going after?"

Seems everyone's satisfied with that, then!

* * *

This is not the first time that I've planned and plotted for something to work
out a specific way and then had it not turn out that way. It's been a while
since I've let something trouble me this bad, but I thought I had my sleight
of hand down.

I try after we finish enjoying breakfast on Koizumi-kun's dime. He doesn't
seem to mind covering the expense, though I get a look from Kyon when I
criticize him

It goes wrong from the beginning-- Kyon gets a marked toothpick instead of an
unmarked one. Koizumi-kun draws the next marked toothpick, and then Mikuru-
chan draws an unmarked toothpick. That's not ideal, but being in a group with
Koizumi-kun and Kyon is alright. It lets me keep them from being distracted by
talking about video games.

That's my _thought_, until Yuki plucks the third marked toothpick. Alright --
I must have gotten some toothpicks switched, somehow. I'll try again after
lunch. Speaking of which:

"This isn't an otaku convention of any kind," I warn the other three sternly.
"I expect you to put real effort into this! The three of you better keep one-
another on track for the investigation-- And pay attention; whoever's last has
to cover our lunch, as well!"

I can't help but think it's going to be Kyon somehow. That's fine, though; I'm
sure if I ding him with a single penalty he'll shape up and stop ending up in
a position where he can get them. Otherwise, well, if he can't put his heart
into it entirely, it's not like I haven't already invested enough of my own
time and money into the club! Those costumes weren't cheap, after all.

Mikuru-chan and I are in a group, and we leave the cafe, heading along the
riverbank as we begin our search. I've checked the river out enough; I still
think alien spacecraft could hide at the bottom, but it's harder and harder to
imagine them pulling it off without anyone noticing.

Mostly, I really want to see what the others find. I hope it's something, at
least!

With just myself, and Mikuru-chan following behind me, I start thinking about
what Yuki mentioned. Should I have a vice commander for the Brigade? Yuki
would have been a thought, but after her prank, she's out of the running.
Koizumi-kun....

If he hadn't been the latest one for our meeting, I'd have given him more
consideration. If he's that bad about punctuality, I can't think he'd be the
best option, though. Well-- If it's neither of those two, I should consider
Mikuru-chan.

But, I don't know ... she's such a cute mascot, wouldn't it all go to waste if
I had her take the role of second-in-command? Probably, I should feel her out
a little more.

When I glance over, she's dropped her moe act again, looking distracted by the
trees, admiring the scenery like she's never had a chance to see plants at
close range before. "So, Mikuru-chan," I say slowly, thinking about that weird
habit she has of just dropping her act. "Who do you think would make a good
second-in-command for the Brigade?"

She makes a disinterested, "Eh?" sound before turning to look at me. She looks
momentarily taken aback, then shrugs. "I don't think you'll find someone
better than Kyon-kun, really," she remarks. "But Koizumi-kun wouldn't be too
bad, I suppose...."

I frown, considering Koizumi-kun again. Still-- "Why's Yuki off the list?"

"Oh, Nagato-san," Mikuru-chan says slowly, looking bothered -- irritated more
than anything else. "Well, I don't think she's demonstrated that she's the
most reliable."

I think about that quietly for a minute. I don't know what triggers the switch
between Mikuru-chan acting all moe or all indifferent.... She's awfully frank,
though. "How does Yuki look unreliable?"

"Um, I guess...." Mikuru-chan trails off and looks thoughtful, then shrugs.
"How has she shown herself to be reliable?"

...that actually sounds almost like antagonism, from Mikuru-chan! What reason
does she have to not like Yuki? Well-- Actually, if she pulled anything off
like she did with me....

"I guess you're right on that count," I sigh, shaking my head. "Arg! I'm still
annoyed with her!"

And then I find myself spending most of our 'mystery search' time grousing
about Yuki's stupid little prank. Bah! I wanted to tell....

...anyway, I finish up, grumbling, "Such a dumb prank!" after I relate the
entire thing to Mikuru-chan. "So-- Unreliable is right! I guess I was just
asking to see what you thought, but I don't want to make her vice commander
either, you know?"

Mikuru-chan looks mostly nonplussed about the entire thing. Almost completely
unsurprised. "She told you that?" she finally asks, turning to look away,
across the glittering surface of the river. "I didn't think anyone from her
faction would bother...."

Yeah-- Wait-- "What?" I ask aloud, surprised. "Her 'faction,' you say?"

Mikuru-chan looks at me -- and there's no trace of her moe-moe act anymore.
She looks older, somehow pitying of me. "Well-- If you didn't believe her,
then you're not likely to believe me, either. Most of it's classified, but if
she's told you that much....

"Myself, I'm a visitor from the future-- You could probably most easily call
me a time traveler. As it happens, around the same time Nagato-san's people
say there was a 'spike of data,' there was an event that confused the time
streams, and prevents traveling back further in time.

"This is something we believe is tied to Kyon-kun--"

"Wait, wait," I protest, shaking my head. "Why-- What--" It's just too much to
process. What, more of the same stupid prank? "Okay, okay-- First of all,
prove that you're a time traveler to me! Don't just say it, give me some solid
evidence!"

"Why do you think I need to prove anything to you?" she returns, shaking her
head. "Calm down and think for a minute; I'm not telling you any of this
because I need you to believe me."

As much as I want to throw a thousand questions at her, I bite my tongue.

When she seems satisfied with my silence, she nods, giving me a glance and
then looking out across the river. "There's so much I simply can't tell you
because it's classified.... I couldn't even _try_ to-- But all the same,
you're caught in the middle of something you can't understand."

"What do you mean?" I manage to keep myself from snapping over this one for
the time being. What's the goal of this dumb prank, anyway?

"Let's be clear," Mikuru-chan replies, looking tired, giving me that same
annoyingly superior look. "None of us are in your club because it's fun --
except maybe for Kyon-kun. Did you _really_ think that members like this would
just come together for you?"

"It didn't-- I had to search for my members!" I counter, scowling. "Like you,
who I hunted down!"

"And all it took was standing in the right place and looking lost in a
daydream," she returns, sighing. "Just when you were hoping to find
someone.... Let's see-- Someone who looked 'cute' and 'harmless' -- someone
non-threatening to you that still held appeal? Someone that even you thought
that Kyon-kun would smile at?"

...that.... That may be _somewhat_ true-- But, no, I worked for that!

"And before that, when you wanted a clubroom, someone else just happened to
have one, and raises no complaint when you take it over," she continues,
sounding annoyed with the idea already, examining her nails with a
particularly intent scowl. "Then you need a fifth person to fill up your club,
and someone shows up who happens to cater to the interest of the most
important person in your club, hmm?"

That shuts me up pretty good.

I'm not sure if it's this whole new face that Mikuru is showing, or what she's
saying--

I never said Kyon was important in my club! I mean ... he is.... He's -- not
that I want to tell him -- responsible for inspiring me to make it! He's a
constant reminder of everything I--

That's not important right now, though! "So, what do you want with him, then?"
I ask. "If-- If that's true! If I could believe this-- So, he's important.
What are you trying to _do_?"

"Let me just say this much," Mikuru returns, giving me a smile that looks
strangely sympathetic. "If you're not careful, you make my assignment ...
_very_ easy." She gives me a doe-eyed look at that, sniffling, slipping
_right_ back into her moe-mode, and for the first time ever, I think I have a
negative reaction to cuteness.

Putting up an act to be cuter is one thing. Covering up something not-at-all-
cute....

I just don't know how to react to that! Another.... Another prank, right?

Except-- Except, ignoring the time traveler and alien nonsense, both of these
girls have a strange way of acting around Kyon for his benefit. And one way or
another, he _is_ at the center of both their stories.

What the _hell_? What is _really_ going on, here?

...I don't find anything worth reporting to the others by the time our search
window ends, though.

* * *

I haven't figured out what to make of Mikuru's little reveal by the time we
get to where we were meeting up for lunch. It takes almost ten minutes for
Kyon's group to show up, but before I can even lay into them, Koizumi-kun
volunteers himself for the penalty.

"I got caught up window-shopping!" he admits, grinning and giving a guilty
shrug, hefting a bag from some electronic supply store. "If I weren't buying
the latest Golden Sun game, we would have been on time. I suppose the penalty
must be mine!"

...how can I adequately judge Kyon if you're always getting penalties like
that, Koizumi-kun?

I sigh and shake my head. Whatever ... if I get the toothpicks to go my way
after we finish eating, I can put that all behind me. Certainly, Koizumi-kun
seems to have some money if he's not upset about getting all these penalties
_and_ he bought a game. Maybe even despite his tardiness he wouldn't be the
worst vice commander?

Thinking about that distracts me. Or else, I must be doing something wrong--
Kyon and Koizumi-kun are in a group again.

Ugh.

When I end up stuck with Yuki, I can't complain -- better her than Mikuru!

...not my ideal group, I admit. I'm actually at a loss on this one; I can
hardly chide Mikuru to keep the other two focused, and Koizumi-kun's too tardy
to be the best example. So, it's actually _Kyon_ I talk to when sending the
other group off. "Be sure to keep those two from getting distracted," I order
him.

He seems surprised to be directly addressed, but both Koizumi-kun and Mikuru
flash him big smiles, as though awaiting his orders. He shrugs in response,
and then motions the others to follow as he sets out on the last leg of
today's planned investigation. The weirdest part is that ... Kyon is probably
the best bet for vice commander of the lot so far.

Mikuru and Yuki are out on account of their stupid prank. Koizumi-kun's just
not reliable enough ... so what other choices do I have?

Better just be quiet about the entire thing, I guess -- not bother mentioning
he's the vice commander until I've had him taking care of the vice commander's
duties for a while.

Still! I'm trying to puzzle out what the heck the real story behind this 'data
creation' and 'temporal anomaly' business is. When Yuki's pace sputters to a
crawl and she falls behind to stare at the sign of the library we're walking
past, I walk on a good dozen yards before realizing I lost her.

I swing back and give her a sharp look. She gives me a totally bland stare in
response.

"What?" I finally snap.

After a moment searching for the right word, her entire response is,
"Unfamiliar."

"What, you've never been to a library before?" I return, a little incredulous.
No _way_ can a girl read like her and not know about the _library_!

But-- She shakes her head in response. It's the kind of head shake you'd need
to be staring at her to catch.

"That's kind of amazing," I return, somewhat acidly. "We're on a mission
today; you'll have to figure it out some other time."

Her head bows the slightest distance. Weirdly, I recall her expression when I
stormed out of her apartment a few days ago. I bite my tongue as I lead her
further away from the library, and we continue our search.

I could take some pity on the girl, show her what a library is and how it
works-- But she owes me an apology or an explanation for that prank, first.
Until I get that, why should I go out of my way to be nicer to her?

* * *

We all gather for the final meeting of the day. I've got nothing to show for
all my searching. Unless I count Mikuru's whole revelation, which I'm _still_
trying to figure out. The others have nothing, either, and under Kyon's
leadership, his group got back on time, making Yuki the last arrival. Kyon
gives me an astounded expression at that, complaining, "She wasn't even late!"

"She was still the last to arrive," I counter. "If people were punished for
being _late_ instead of _last_, then you would be in trouble from this
morning!"

"It is fine," Yuki cuts in, when Kyon looks about to protest further.

What, Kyon doesn't mind a guy paying for the girls, but a girl paying for the
guys bothers him? Anyway-- We go back to the cafe and order our dinners.
Despite Kyon looking like he's about to protest, he doesn't stop her.

But ignoring all of that, for an entire day of searching, we've found nothing
at all interesting.

Unless I count Mikuru's story. I'm not happy with the way things turned out,
so as we're leaving, I warn everyone, "We're going to review this again
tomorrow! We didn't find a single thing?" Sure, I was distracted, but what's
Kyon's excuse? How do he and Koizumi-kun do in groups, anyway?

Bah-- We'll find out tomorrow!

* * *

Class goes pretty slowly after the weekend. Without anything better to do than
mull over the search, I try and think back to Mikuru and Yuki's stories.

Kyon as some kind of super-important guy. That was the main thing they agreed
on, anyway. How could someone so boring _really_ be so important?

I guess part of me wouldn't mind if it were _true_. Mostly, I just think that
it's so hard to believe because ... well.... Because it's Kyon!

I don't really want to pick on Yuki because I already took her room. Mikuru,
though, doesn't have a very good excuse at all. Given that, and how her moe
act is just an act, I decide to dig a bit.

Evading Sakanaka and Yanagimoto, I quickly track Mikuru down to an empty
classroom-- The same one I found her in the first time, actually. She's got
the same dreamy, distracted expression on her face, too.

"Alright," I bark at her, slamming my cafeteria tray on an empty desk next to
hers.

She startles a little, then gives me a curious look.

"Tell me more about time travel," I order her.

"Oh," she answers after a moment, smoothing her skirt and giving me a puzzled
look. "That's all classified. There's nothing I can _really_ tell you. You
have to realize -- generally, the only information I can give you is
information that doesn't change anything. You can't think I'd be allowed to
risk altering the timeline, do you?"

At least she and Yuki seem to have thought out their excuses for not being
able to show proof.

"Tell me about Yuki," I stay instead. It's a long shot, but if I can get her
to give me holes in Yuki's story -- or the other way around -- at least I can
_disprove_ it and set things to rest.

"I really can't tell you anything you don't already know," Mikuru answers
smoothly, now looking slightly amused at my expression. "Even if I wanted to,
as soon as I tried to say anything, I'd just end up saying, 'classified
information.'"

"Well, I didn't know you were claiming to be a time traveler," I counter. "You
told me that just fine!"

"Because that wouldn't change anything," she agrees, shrugging, the gesture
seeming somehow rough from her. "And now maybe you're ready to believe -- or
would just pass things on to someone else. So, now I can't tell you anything
else!"

...I'm beginning to really hate this stupid game. I liked her moe-moe act just
fine when it wasn't so _creepy_. I'd have been happier if she really _was_
that way instead of just _pretending_. Now it's starting to piss me off!

* * *

By the time club rolls around, I'm still ticked off at Mikuru. Hey, it's not
like it's unprovoked! Of course, I got so caught up in it that I totally
forgot my plans, until Kyon asks me, "So, today is review for yesterday, is
it?"

I don't want to be unreliable or inconsistent. I especially don't like letting
a bad precedent slide! But I'm not in a good mindset to search the city today.
I guess I could try doing it alone, but that'd take longer. While I wouldn't
mind getting away from Mikuru for a bit and thinking about things, I also
don't like the idea of doing that -- it feels too much like letting her win.

"I decided to let it pass since it was our first review," I grumble. Or, no,
wait-- I have a better idea! "We'll just do the same one again next week, and
keep our eyes sharper!"

"Is that so?" Kyon muses, looking at me curiously, giving me an annoyingly
indulgent smile.

Ugh. "Mikuru-chan, you look great in that outfit," I tell our mascot, which
gets her to give me a tiny, vapid smile of her own from where she's huddling
near the tea set. I'm not really into her act, but if it's just an act, I
think there's no problem with working on sexier, more interesting pictures for
the website.

Come to think of it-- "You've got to amp up the moe a bit, though; if you're
carrying the tea perfectly and never spilling it, you're not dojiko enough!
There's still some parts of your act that you could pick up!"

"Huh?" she noises in confusion, just as Kyon snags his drink from the tray,
looking at me dubiously.

"Mm, yeah," I continue, nodding. A little bit, yeah, I'm picking on Mikuru.
But this is nothing considering to the game her and Yuki are trying to have at
my expense! "You need to spill the tea at least two out of every five times!
You must practice getting really good at it, until you can make the cup flip
over and over -- and then land upside-down on Kyon's head!"

She stares at me blankly, so I swipe the serving tray from her and then snatch
the teacup as soon as Kyon sets it down.

"H...how do you mean?" she asks in that innocent, oblivious way she's
cultivated.

I top off Kyon's teacup to show her, then hold up the tray on the palm of one
hand and set Kyon's cup on it. I turn around to demonstrate, but Kyon's
already standing behind there, plucking the cup off the tray before I can even
start.

"Hey!" I can't help but snap, shooting him a scowl. Where's his sense of fun?

He returns a level look, raising his eyebrows. "I don't _want_ hot tea dumped
on my head, Suzumiya," he returns. "If you're so eager for Asahina-san to
learn something dumb like that, let her practice on you."

"At least then you'd be active in _doing_ something involving the club," I
grumble, looking away. How can he call it _dumb_? Does he not realize it's an
_act_? Maybe he's just unhappy because he thinks that it's at his expense? One
tiny little cup of spilled tea?

That's nothing, considering what Mikuru and Yuki put _me_ through!

"More pictures for the website," I decide, nodding. Yeah-- If we're not amping
up that moe act, we might as well do something productive for the club! I'll
get some pictures of Mikuru in her bunny-girl costume, and then once she's
done playing up her reluctant act, I'll wear mine, too! I think pictures of us
should be fine! The pictures of both of us together will be the final act of
that little slide-show -- I think those will bring in _tons_ of hits!

Yuki would probably be who I should hand the camera to, but maybe I'll let
Kyon do it, instead? I can just say for the website that Mikuru took all the
pictures of me. Guys love the idea of girls doing stuff like that, right? Come
for the moe, stay for the sexy -- and then get suckered into finding out how
awesome the Brigade really is!

Yeah! That sounds like a good plan--

Of course, it doesn't even _get_ that far, because as soon as I go to start
taking Mikuru's costume off, Kyon doesn't just complain, he actually grabs my
hand and drags me away! I shoot him a glare and try to pull away a little bit.
He's still stronger than me, though, so as much as it sucks, there's _nothing_
I can do about it!

So unfair.... I can't help but be angry at that-- That he's choosing _now_ to
totally buy into Mikuru's moe-moe act? Of course, you _would_ side with her,
wouldn't you, Kyon? I thought you were on _my_ side! And now you throw it all
away for a helpless act and a pretty face?

I don't even realize what's going on until he shoots me a dark look, like he's
not really sure what to say, then just grumbles, "You need to respect Asahina-
san more." After that, he crosses his arms and looks dissatisfied, letting go
of my wrist and not meeting my eyes.

Hey-- Respect is a two way street, and her act this weekend was _not_ a good
start with me! As irritated as I am about things, I stop trying to go after
Mikuru's costume and tell Kyon, "You buy into her act too much-- Or you're
just putting up an _act_ of looking out for her, yourself!"

He falls silent and looks away at that--

Yeah, that's his weak point, alright. That Mikuru plays up the moe, and he was
too slow to properly play 'hero' for her earlier? When I look over, his
attention is on the floor, and weirdly enough, instead of looking offended,
Mikuru looks more ... I dunno ... sad for me than anything else? Why would she
pity me?

That's the part I can't make sense of at all, but that's not important at the
moment. "It's a bit late to try and play the 'white knight' card now!" I snap,
glaring at him. "But if you two are both so phony, at least you're a matched
set that way!"

He looks about ready to snap something back, but instead of saying anything,
he just gives a small shake of his head and leaves the room.

The second he's out of sight, Koizumi-kun sighs, checking his cell-phone and
excusing himself with an absent-sounding mumble. He doesn't even wait for me
to acknowledge his departure!

As if there weren't enough people telling me that Kyon was the real center of
my club-- With him gone, Mikuru's act is dried up, and she just shakes her
head sadly at me -- like _I_ screwed up by calling Kyon out? Yuki watches me
quietly, Koizumi-kun obviously couldn't have cared less since he's already
gone....

I don't bother with orders -- Mikuru can change herself, and Yuki doesn't need
my help to lock up.

The day's a waste anyway, but maybe if I leave early enough I can review at
least half of the weekend assignment and salvage some of the review. The fact
that I can avoid my mom a little longer is really just a bonus.

It's not until it's late, when it's almost dark that I realize ... I just
spent the rest of my time outside of club retracing Kyon's footsteps anyway.

He really _is_ at the middle of everything. If I believe just that one small
part of what Yuki and Mikuru were saying....

* * *